Les, I think the spare tire key on my 2007 is common with something else, but I can't remember what. I too am challenged when removing and installing the spare tire cover. I found moving the handle one way and then the other way, helps in turning the key. Also try pushing with the palm of the one hand, leaning hard on the center of the cover almost with a jerk, when turning the key. Also when you go to install the cover, the key works in only one of two 180 degree positions. When I tighten the handle all the way, I have to unscrew it 180 degrees to turn the key to lock it. It is tempermental, but after a couple tries, it's understood what it takes to make it work. It really is a nice design when you come to understand it. Ron