Trudy,
I have had the brush type on two motorhomes and the solid skirt type on one. I prefer the brush since it tends to knock things down and not ricochet around like the skirt type does. I put one on my 2700 and so far no dings on the toad. The skirt on the HR really didn't do all that well protecting the pickup I pulled then, the hood was pretty hammered when I sold it and also the skirt let ''stuff'' hit the side of the truck. That is not happening on the brush type I have now. I also did not get a full MH width brush, it is only a little wider than my toad an so far the sides of the toad are nick free.
L. G.